28 Comments
User's avatar
Mary Holscher's avatar

So powerful in its elongated "falling" form, its metaphor of "a cracked robin’s egg disgorging black swans," the poignancy of "some say" before the beautiful final line. Thank you for writing and sharing this today, as my own thoughts lean toward "praying backward."

Expand full comment
Deborah Kay Kelly's avatar

blue perfection was a cracked robin’s egg

disgorging black swans

oh my, yes

Expand full comment
Deborah Kay Kelly's avatar

and this:

outside time’s ambit the zone where some say

we can pray backwards they were not alone

Expand full comment
Janie Braverman's avatar

We were living in Denver. One of my daughters was downtown, in class, when they began to evacuate downtown. The ripple of fear across the country.

This is gorgeous work. The lines, the lineation, the spacing. Taking us back to that very hard day.

Expand full comment
Janie Braverman's avatar

and this: the bright face of burning empire

burning still

Expand full comment
X. P. Callahan's avatar

🔥

Thanks, Janie. The poem, like so many of mine, is syllabic. I was working here, for the first time, with Richard Howard's 7/10/10 tercets (modeled, of course, on the syllabics of Marianne Moore).

Expand full comment
Alexis R Kane's avatar

One of your best. Not a moment of cliché. No worries on that with you! Powerful, moving, exquisite.

Expand full comment
Laura Pilnick's avatar

Beautiful and terrifying

Expand full comment
Corey Smith's avatar

That last line.

Expand full comment
Pam Weeks's avatar

I like the riff and language running through -almost the national anthem falling away as it has since then

Expand full comment
X. P. Callahan's avatar

It certainly has, along with a number of items in the Bill of Rights. And for what?

Expand full comment
pamm hanson's avatar

I have carried this poem with me all day, trying to imagine how to write a comment. To me, each word of this poem holds the space. It is spare, and deep. So much is expressed in these words, in these spaces between words. so I say wow. just wow. oh! and thank you. xo

Expand full comment
pamm hanson's avatar

I thought about this poem all day yesterday, intimidated by how I could ever make a comment. It seems to me this says it all. Feels circular, round, to me in some (odd) way. An astounding poem.

Expand full comment
X. P. Callahan's avatar

Thank you for telling me. Such a rich and generous response. ❤️

Expand full comment
<Mary L. Tabor>'s avatar

Striking! Well-done and glad you found me through my essay on 9-11.

Expand full comment
Laura Pilnick's avatar

Haunting

Expand full comment
Celeste's avatar

Such a powerful piece. thank you!

Expand full comment
LeeAnn Pickrell's avatar

Thank you for reposting this, X.P. This is such a powerful poem. I think we all remember where we were that morning, what we were doing. I can remember just standing in front of the TV watching people jump.

Expand full comment
X. P. Callahan's avatar

Even in Seattle, where I was getting ready to go to my job downtown, we worried that nowhere was safe. Horrifying.

Expand full comment
Margaret Ann Silver's avatar

Your poem has stayed with me all day. It is so beautiful and sad.

Expand full comment
X. P. Callahan's avatar

Thank you so much, Margaret Ann. Yours with me as well.

Expand full comment
Margaret Ann Silver's avatar

That means a lot. Thank you.

Expand full comment